Graduate School
|
JAN
11
2011
2
AM
|
"The mathematics of narcissism"
Fellow mathematician Jordan Ellenberg has an unusual take on the NRC's rankings: in Slate he compares the NRC's approach to ranking graduate programs to a new method psychologists are using for classifying mental illnesses.
The article is worth reading in full, but the gist of it is that there are two standard ap...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
DEC
28
2010
5
PM
|
Professional Science
A heartening holiday article in the NY Times this week: A Master’s for Science Professionals Sweeps U.S. Schools. The Professional Science Masters is catching on big time:
> The degree, which a few universities quietly pioneered in the mid-1990s, combines graduate studies in science or mathematics and business m...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
DEC
17
2010
2
AM
|
Students know effective teaching when they see it
So says the Measures of Effective Teaching Project, a major ($45M) effort to assess teacher quality funded by the Gates Foundation. Preliminary findings were released earlier in the week.
Key quote from the report:
> When a teacher teaches multiple classes, student perceptions of his or her practice are remar...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
NOV
21
2010
1
AM
|
Rankings update
Quiet on the blog is often good news: it means that web site improvements are in thw works. Today we've rolled out some nice speedups of the rankings site.
One of the hazards of working with great hardware and software when developing a site is that it's easy to forget that there are lots of people running old b...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
NOV
13
2010
2
AM
|
Graduate enrollments are up
The Council of Graduate Schools has released their annual report on graduate enrollments here.
Here's their key point:
> “The strong growth in first-time graduate enrollment is an indication of the continued high value of graduate education,” said CGS President Debra W. Stewart. “In particular, the 6.0% gain ...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
OCT
29
2010
2
PM
|
Rankings changes
Those of you in Communication Research may have noticed something strange about the NRC R-rankings for the field on our site: until yesterday, the confidence intervals for programs almost all started at 1. That means that in our simulated rankings, almost all programs ended up in first place at least 25 times. Why...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
OCT
22
2010
3
AM
|
NRC corrections?
From the NRC's web site:
> Some institutions, when they examine the spreadsheet for the database of the National Research Council study A Data-Based Assessment of Research-Doctorate Programs, may find data that are or appear to be incorrect. Over the next several weeks following public release of the report and d...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
OCT
12
2010
2
AM
|
NRC Data Quality, Part 2
Over the weekend I received another irate email from a department chair bemoaning the grievous and irreparable harm the terrible errors on phds.org were causing his program. I investigated. It turned out that the data in question came from the NSF's Survey of Graduate Students and Postdoctorates in Science and Eng...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
OCT
08
2010
2
PM
|
NRC Data Quality
In the wake of the new graduate school rankings, we have received a handful of emails from department chairs who are angry about alleged errors in the NRC's data. The emails by and large follow a pattern: "This specific piece of information about my program is wrong, therefore the data from the NRC are highly flawe...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
SEP
28
2010
4
PM
|
New Graduate School Guide
A little later this afternoon we will be launching a big update of our graduate school guide. The upgrade includes the long awaited new rankings from the National Research Council as well as new data from the National Science Foundation and IPEDS.
We've also done a big upgrade of the look of the site with an e...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
JUN
30
2010
12
AM
|
You sure you want that chemistry PhD?
An choice memo from a CalTech professor chastising a student for failing to work nights and weekends is making the rounds on the web.
> "In addition to the usual work-day schedule, I expect all of the members of the group to work evenings and weekends," Carreira wrote. "You will find that this is the norm here at...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
JAN
20
2010
4
PM
|
PE for grad students
Another study links aerobic exercise to increased cognitive performance:
Start running and watch your brain grow, say scientists
Running (a lot of it) was found to improve the performance of mice on tests of memory. The mechanism: increased neurogenesis.
There's a fair amount of evidence that exercise boos...
read more
|
TAGGED
POSTED BY
|
|
JAN
19
2010
6
PM
|
Be thankful you aren't in the humanities
The title says it all: "Graduate School in the Humanities: Just Don't Go". A particularly grim line:
> ...some responsible observers expect that hiring may be down 40 percent this year. What is 40 percent worse than desperate?
Something that rings true beyond the humanities is the author's characterization ...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
AUG
20
2009
3
PM
|
PhD retraining program
Did your graduate program not provide you with useful skills beyond what you needed to write your dissertation? MIT can help! A piece in today's NY Times describes MIT's Career Re-engineering program for scientists and engineers.
There's definitely a need for this kind of training - people's careers and interes...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
JUL
10
2009
4
PM
|
NRC rankings are getting closer...
The methodology report for the forthcoming NRC rankings is out. It's an interesting approach to ranking programs, but it's complicated. For those without a statistics background, I'm sure it's conceptually pretty weird.
In the short term, the NRC rankings have two weaknesses: first, they're quite late, and se...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
JUN
05
2009
1
AM
|
Rankings Ruckus at Clemson
A former Clemson institutional researcher has just given an eye-opening presentation that described how the US News college rankings drove the agenda of Clemson's administration. The measures taken ranged from promising (decreases in class sizes and increases in admissions standards) to unethical (allegations that ...
read more
|
TAGGED
POSTED BY
|
|
MAY
25
2009
8
PM
|
Lab Safety?
There's an interesting piece in Slate this week about lab safety (or the lack thereof) in academic settings relative to their corporate counterparts. The author may be familiar to some - Beryl Lieff Benderly writes for Science's Next Wave.
The article describes an awful chem lab accident at UCLA and then goes on...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
APR
28
2009
2
AM
|
"End the University as We Know It"
There's an op-ed in yesterday's Times with a great opening paragraph:
> Graduate education is the Detroit of higher learning. Most graduate programs in American universities produce a product for which there is no market (candidates for teaching positions that do not exist) and develop skills for which there is d...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
JAN
27
2009
4
PM
|
"A Bad Reputation: Why are more and more graduate students turning away from careers at research universities?"
Mary Ann Mason and Marc Goulden have conducted a recent study of University of California graduate students. Mason's assessment in *The Chronicle*: "We may be losing some of the most talented potential academics before they even arrive for a job interview. In the eyes of many doctoral students, the research univers...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
JUL
16
2008
4
PM
|
So graduate school is good for what, exactly?
A new TIAA-CREF survey of junior faculty at Master's granting colleges shows that alarmingly low numbers feel prepared for their jobs at the time of hiring.
The interesting bit is Table 7, "Level of preparation for career responsibilities"
After graduate school, % "very effectively" prepared:
Conduct resear...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
MAY
03
2008
4
PM
|
Privacy paranoia at NSF?
Inside Higher Ed has an article with Orwellian-sounding overtones: Data on Minority Doctorates Suppressed. The gist of it is that NSF has tightened up its privacy rules and will no longer be reporting information on the ethnicity of doctorates when the cell size is 5 or smaller.
The trouble is that basic repor...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
APR
24
2008
2
AM
|
PE for grad students, part 2
This month's *Wired* has more on the exercise/cognitive function connection : aerobic exercise helps, weight lifting doesn't.
They also have a rundown on drugs that allegedly enhance cognitive functioning, handy for any who are thinking about emulating the 20% of scientists admitting to using brain-boosting drugs...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
APR
22
2008
2
PM
|
PE for grad students?
Do the following strike you as things that graduate students or postdocs excel at?
> * make plans
> * keep track of time
> * keep track of more than one thing at once
> * meaningfully include past knowledge in discussions
> * engage in group dynamics
> * evaluate ideas
> * reflect on our work
> * change ou...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
APR
16
2008
2
AM
|
Graduate Education at Stanford
Mark Horowitz, Associate Vice Provost for Graduate Education at Stanford, gave a talk at Google a few weeks ago about some of the things Stanford is working on to enhance the quality of its graduate programs. After many years (a decade or more?) of having no senior leadership with responsibility for graduate educat...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
FEB
06
2008
2
AM
|
Graduate School Guidance
One key data set I used in building the Graduate School Guide was IPEDS, which is put out by the Department of Education's National Center for Education Statistics. IPEDS is incredibly useful for this kind of thing: the data set contains a near-complete list of all colleges and universities in the country together ...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
MAY
10
2007
4
PM
|
Meanwhile in the Senate...
I've just taken a look at the Senate's hefty bill to reauthorize the NSF, S 761. Like the House equivalent, there are some good and interesting things in the bill.
* There is a lot of new money for graduate fellowships:
**IGERT** - Increased funding to the IGERT program, like in the House bill. This would fu...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
APR
26
2007
8
PM
|
More Graduate Students - Brought to You by IGERT
The increase in graduate students discussed earlier in the week just came a step closer to reality: the House and Senate just passed a set of bills that will steer a big chunk of funding toward new graduate fellowships, among other things. I assume there will be some negotiation in conference over the final form, b...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
APR
24
2007
4
PM
|
More Graduate Students?
There have been a few bills working their way through Congress that seek to significantly increase the number of graduate students. Why now, at a time when people are asking, "Are we training too many PhDs?"
Much of the current impetus comes from the National Academies report, Rising Above the Gathering Storm --...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
APR
18
2007
4
PM
|
Student journalism
I was on the faculty of the math department at Dartmouth for 4 years. Dartmouth has a wonderful department, full of smart, engaging people doing great work. One of the things I liked best about the department was that the local culture strongly values teaching in addition to research. That's true of the College a...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
APR
09
2007
7
PM
|
The Scientific Communications Act of 2007
There's an interesting new bill working its way through the House: The Scientific Communications Act of 2007. (A tip of the hat to the fine folks over at ArsTechnica for cluing me in to its existence).
The bill allocates $50 million over 5 years to the NSF to improve the communication skills of S&E graduate stud...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
APR
02
2007
12
AM
|
Career Outcomes and Rankings
First of all, Happy April Fool’s Day – I think this day should be a nationally recognized holiday for PhDs, not only because so many of the best April Fool’s jokes have come from the ranks of scientists but also because of the lamentable condition many PhD grads find themselves in from an employment standpoint.
B...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|
|
MAR
30
2007
3
PM
|
phds.org in the News
Scott Jaschik has written a nice piece on the new rankings at Inside Higher Ed. Here's the story.
|
TAGGED
POSTED BY
|
|
MAR
29
2007
9
PM
|
New Graduate School Rankings
Things have been a bit quiet here because I have been busy working on an expansion of phds.org: a new set of graduate school rankings. Take a look!
Here is what's new:
* **Program profiles** - We now have detailed profiles of ~6,000 graduate programs at 418 US universities; altogether there are more than 25,0...
read more
|
POSTED BY
|